District 112 Teachers Take First Step Towards Strike

Despite the help of a federal mediator, contract negotiations between teachers and the Highland Park elementary and middle school district are not going well.

The District 112 teachers' union declared an impasse in its contract negotiations with the school board last week, a decision that could lead to a teachers' strike by the middle of next month.

The teachers' current contract expired Aug. 21. Since then, the North Shore Education Association (NSEA) — the teachers' union — has been meeting with the district's school board to negotiate a new contract. Even with the assistance of a federal mediator, the talks have not gone far.

Want Highland Park news in your inbox every morning? Subscribe to Patch's newsletter.

Union position

"We went in with about half a million dollars a year in health insurance concessions," NSEA president Pamela Kramer said. "Even with that they still want to freeze our salaries."

Kramer said much of the union's frustration comes from the way the new contract cuts rewards to teachers for pursuing higher accreditation. Previously, the district gave teachers a 1.5 percent raise for 18 hours of graduate credits, according to Kramer. In the new contract, that raise has been replaced by a $250 stipend.

The stipend, combined with a salary freeze that would prevent raises except for cost of living increases, means it would take teachers 20 years to make back the thousands of dollars teachers spend from their own pockets on higher learning, according to Kramer.

"What that would do in this district is teachers would come, work in this district for a year or two and then leave to a district that pays better," Kramer said. An English and dual language teacher, Kramer has taught in Highland Park for 12 years. "You don't want teachers that come and hightail it to Lake Forest and Deerfield where they get better pay."

Kramer believes the district's reluctance to be more generous with its teachers stems from its unnecessarily gloomy outlook on its own financial state.

"The money is there … it just depends on how you look at the future," Kramer said. "Do you look at it as doom and gloom? The economy is getting better."

Board position

District 112 Community Relations Specialist Andi Rosen told Patch the district has a very clear idea of what its finances will look like and wants to make sure expenditures don't exceed revenue.

"We can project very accurately what the revenue will be like," Rosen said. She added that the teachers' union used Kramer's argument three years ago, and as a result the district gave out salary increases to teachers that ended up going "well above the revenues," $2.65 million from its 2013 budget earlier this year.

"It's not in the best interests of the teachers if the board is in a position where further cuts have to be made," Rosen said. "At some point it starts to affect class sizes."

Rosen declined to elaborate on Kramer's concerns, but said that the district's new proposed contract would be published online on Sept. 21. In the meantime, Rosen acknowledged that negotiations still had a long way to go.

"The board and the union came to the table hoping to talk to each other and reach a settlement," Rosen said, "but they are quite far apart."

What's next

The declaration of impasse came last Friday, days after the teachers voted to authorize the negotiations team to strike if bargaining sessions continued to be unproductive. The union and the board have until Sept. 21 to submit their most recent contract proposals to the Illinois Educational Labor Relations Board, and then another seven days to post those proposals on the agency's website. The earliest the strike could legally begin is Oct. 12.

But that won't stop teachers from rallying before then. Kramer said that teachers will rally outside of the District 112 School Board meeting on Tuesday evening at 7 p.m. at the District Administrative Officed, 1936 Green Bay Road.

District 112 teachers have also taken to the Internet to reach out to the community about its concerns. They have set up a Facebook page and are blogging about the negotiations on the union's website.

"It's a new school board," Kramer said. "I think they'll be surprised to find out that the community values its teachers."

The next mediation session between the board and the union will be held on Oct. 4. 

For more news and updates, "like" us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.

David Greenberg September 28, 2012 at 05:22 PM
John, I agree it's totally insane. We need to move away from a Defined Benefit to a Defined Contribution - with two options: A) The teacher manages their own investments; B) The "Fund" manages the investments. Changes should be allowed once every 10 years. No guarantees as to value - may go up or down. May lose value. And as their salary goes up - the taxpayer's contribution should decrease accordingly. When they're making $100K/yr, the taxpayers should contribute ZERO. When they're making under $50K/yr, OK, I'll bite and say that the 'social compact' about making less than in the private sector applies so we ought to contribute something - not the whole 9.4%, but something substantial. TRS's assumptions of an 8% return are totally off-base as well. They need to be CONSERVATIVE, not aggressive with their predictions...
John Sullivan September 28, 2012 at 05:40 PM
They've only averaged 4% over the past ten years, and only 1% over the last fiscal year. The difference triples to quadruples the unfunded portion. Of course, no one in Illinois expects these large pots of public money to be "on the legit", as the Cellini trial illustrated. The teachers never had to care about corruption in their pension fund because the taxpayers had to make up the difference. However, now it is apparent that the Illinois economy will never be able to pay more than a fraction of it's obligations and they should care very much indeed. Oh, well, when the money runs out, the money runs out.....
Lou September 28, 2012 at 06:10 PM
Remember, families move to Highland Park because of our schools, that's what we are known for, not the rude and careless drivers (and bicyclists) who "own" the roads here. New Orleans has great food, Los Angeles the movie "stars" and Highland Park has the greatest schools and teachers, all my kids loved their elementary and middle schools in HP. One cannot say that about too many other schools in our once great nation. Let's support the teachers, they support us.
Me September 28, 2012 at 06:41 PM
I am from Lake Forest and I just have to laugh at the situation. We were just strong-armed into a ridiculous settlement because we were told that if we didn't agree to outlandish raises, then the best teachers would all hot foot it on down the road to........you guessed it, Highland Park. Now, the teachers are extorting the Highland Park taxpayers, telling them that all of the good ones will run up to Lake Forest if the raises are not given. Just wait until the teachers make a video on how passionate they are about teaching. It will bring a tear to your eye (sniff, sniff). Taxpayers, you may want to bite down on this strap because you will probably feel a bit of pressure.
John Sullivan September 28, 2012 at 06:59 PM
Sorry to say, after the election, our esteemed politicians are expected to start dumping pension payments on local school districts. Instead of pension reform, we will get another tax increase and more increases as far as the eye can see. Despite this, many teachers will have to be laid off and their salaries will increase from the 85% of the budget that they now hog. Class sizes will have to increase and student outcomes will continue to decline, but at a faster pace. But, what the heck! A drivers ed teacher SHOULD make $190,000/yr. District 15 just had a P.E. teacher retire with a salary of $203,000/yr and a pension of $150,000/yr. At a 5% cost of money, that pension has a lump sum value of $4 million dollars. Just like your 401k!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »